The Killing Myths

Director of Waterworks, You Must! Why Democracies Produce Kamikazes

Director of Waterworks, You Must! Why Democracies Produce Kamikazes

We declare an absolute love for the rule of law, institutional procedures, and stable systems. Why, then, in moments of crisis, do we immediately flee into the archaic order of myth, dismiss the accountants, and demand superhero capes and suicidal charges from our state managers? Presenting an analysis of the Amazing Kamikadze System – a social technology where the crowd, from a safe distance, outsources its own courage, buys tickets to a daily political spectacle, and panics at the thought of boring, efficient state engineering.

Modern public debate suffers from a peculiar, deeply rooted ailment: it carries respect for institutions, procedures, and constitutional frameworks on its banners, but emotionally and subconsciously, it believes solely in heroes. Whenever a crisis arrives – whether real, imagined, or cleverly manufactured by the media – we instantly abandon rational thinking about state structures and flee into the safe, tribal world of myth. Instead of a competent administrator who coldly calculates costs and manages risk with a calculator in hand, we expect a protagonist. We want a guy with a cape who will step into a burning skyscraper without hesitation, while everyone else stands behind the police tape with bated breath.

Thus is born the Amazing Kamikadze System – a social technology of outsourcing courage, in which the crowd, from a safe distance, delegates risk to a designated volunteer. It is a highly perverse and, at its core, deeply selfish mechanism, though it disguises itself in the finest feathers of heroism. A simple pattern emerges here: the louder the crowd shouts "You must!", the less it has to do itself. On the surface, such a slogan looks like a dramatic plea for rescue and an expression of the highest trust. Beneath it, however, lies something far more brutal and utilitarian: "You will bear the costs and risks that we have no intention of bearing. You go first into the minefield, and we will cheer from a safe distance or comment on your spectacular downfall."

The Gravitational Model and the Hollywood Myth

Pop culture provides the blueprint for this model of debate. In the classic action movie Die Hard, everyone sensible around – from bureaucrats to operational commanders – talks about procedures, jurisdictions, waiting for backup, and avoiding unnecessary risk. Then John McClane walks in, drops a brief "no time," and crawls barefoot over broken glass, taking a massive beating, but single-handedly dismantles the enemy's system and saves the hostages. In the political imagination of many commentators and voters, the highest offices in the state should be cast precisely according to this Hollywood selection. Most interestingly, both sides of a polarized conflict are watching the same movie. Supporters see an uncompromising action hero on the edge; opponents see a desperate man breaking procedures and causing chaos. Yet, both agree on the fundamental frame: this is a spectacle about a lone rider upon whom everything depends.

However, the Hollywood frame has a habit of brutally and deliberately removing elements crucial to the actual functioning of societies. Namely, it removes what can be called private gravity. In the cinema, no one asks about McClane’s mortgage payment, his blood pressure, his fatigue, or his wife’s opinion. In real life, next to every figure delegated by the crowd to a suicidal mission, a loved one sits in the proverbial white nightgown and says: "Think about it, man, is it worth it? You should take care of the family, think about us." The crowd gathered under the window immediately roars back, drowning out that voice: "Don't listen to her! Jump from the roof onto the helicopter!"

In this way, the political kamikaze becomes the center of a small planetary system, torn apart by three powerful, conflicting gravitational fields:

• Historical gravity (macro): A massive social suction generating tales of a historic moment, higher purposes, and being called upon by History.

• The gravity of one's own ambition: The leader's internal conviction of their own uniqueness, a deeply ingrained sense of mission built over years, which no one else can carry.

• The gravity of the immediate environment (micro perspective): A world where no one talks about historical greatness or symbolic gains, but about real consequences, loss of health, psychological exhaustion, and the brutal question: "What will happen to us in a year, in five years, when this game ends?"

From the perspective of social engineering, this system is extremely economical. You don't need an army of heroes – one volunteer is enough, the rest can comfortably remain the audience. Furthermore, the more hopeless the mission seems, the greater the moral prestige gained by the one who steps into the cockpit. The crowd cleverly hedges for both scenarios. If the volunteer wins, he will be proclaimed the savior of the nation. If he falls, he will gain the status of a hallowed martyr, and the audience will shed a tear over his beautiful disaster before returning to their safe daily routines.

In this setup, the ideal kamikaze must already be somewhat politically worn out. When a young, likeable, and promising politician is sent to the front, natural resistance and empathy kick in within society: "It's a bit of a pity, he has his whole life and career ahead of him." For an experienced veteran who has already completed the full cycle – winning, losing, serving as prime minister, leaving, returning – this resistance completely vanishes. The crowd assumes that he knows exactly what he is signing up for, has lived his life, and is perfectly suited to be a political lightning rod – a man whose fate after the mission can be brushed aside as an acceptable cost of the operation.

What the System Says, or the Anatomy of Constitutional Betrayal

The greatest paradox lies in the fact that it is precisely the liberal and democratic circles – by definition the most sensitive to the fate of the individual, civil rights, and institutional safeguards – that are most eager to abandon these principles in favor of collective goal-oriented thinking in times of intense political conflict. At that moment, the individual becomes the vessel for a mission, rather than a human being with his own limitations. To justify the need for a kamikaze, a false myth of the omnipotence of the prime minister's office is constructed, completely distorting the essence of the supreme law of the land.

If, instead of watching political soap operas, we were to open the text of the Constitution, we would see a system deliberately designed as the antithesis of one-man messianism:

• Executive power does not have a single brain. According to Article 10, Paragraph 2, executive power is exercised by the President of the Republic of Poland and the Council of Ministers. The system is based on continuous balancing and friction between these two centers, not on the dictate of a single leader.

• The government is not a chieftain's committee, but a subordinate body. Article 95, Paragraph 2 states clearly: The Sejm shall exercise control over the activities of the Council of Ministers within the scope specified by the provisions of the Constitution and statutes. Continuous reporting, explaining oneself to parliament, and accounting for every step is not a whim of the opposition, but a foundation of the state's political system.

• The President is not a "guardian of the chandelier." Article 126 and Article 134 equip the head of state with real, potent powers – from legislative vetoes and ensuring compliance with the Constitution, to the supreme command of the Armed Forces. The Prime Minister does not operate in a vacuum; he collides with an institution carrying a strong, sovereign mandate.

• The Council is meant to counsel and implement, not to rule. The crucial Article 146, Paragraph 1 indicates that the Council of Ministers shall conduct the internal and foreign policy of the Republic of Poland. Paragraph 2 adds that matters of state policy not reserved for other organs shall belong to the Council of Ministers. At the same time, the very same article imposes strictly bureaucratic duties upon it: ensuring the implementation of statutes, directing the governmental administration, or executing the budget.

The Constitution, therefore, speaks of an executive team operating within a dense web of limitations, budgets, court rulings, and international obligations. There is no room there for a bureaucratic demiurge of reality. Yet, public debate ignores this structure, framing the prime minister as a man who, by the sheer force of his will, can and should break institutional boundaries. The slogan "You must!" assumes something deeply anarchic: the suggestion that procedures are not enough, so we need someone who will do more than the normal functioning of the system allows. The more we analyze the psychology of leaders, the less we analyze the mechanics of the state.

The Four States of Matter of the Myth

In such an arrangement, the political kamikaze undergoes an inevitable evolution. Just like in physics, the substance of the heroic myth changes its states of matter depending on the temperature of social emotions.

Kamikadze ---> Bolesław ---> Premier-streamer ---> Antykamikadze (Flight Phase) (Symbol Phase) (Serial Phase) (Engineering Phase)

  1. Kamikaze (The Flight Phase)

The volunteer fully accepts the role imposed on him. Only the goal matters: striking the opponent, breaking through the wall, executing the charge. In this phase, no one – neither the pilot nor his fans – asks questions about what will happen in five or ten years. The sole focus is on executing the task here and now. The mere fact of undertaking a fight that others were afraid to face becomes the highest symbolic value. Effectiveness takes a backseat; what matters is the readiness to fly.

  1. The Archetype of the Veteran-Symbol (The Bolesław Phase)

This is the most tragic moment of the entire cycle: a kamikaze who survived his own suicide mission and... crashed into the very ship he was supposed to destroy. When the great historical battle ends, society moves on; it wants normalcy. However, the old hero cannot take off the uniform and leave the barricade. Since he was once absolutely indispensable for saving the world, he believes he must always be present and indispensable, because normalcy would mean a painful admission that the mission is over.

At this point, the man completely loses control over his own symbol and the way people talk about him. He begins to desperately remind the audience of his past merits, demanding recognition here and now. The scene where the old veteran shouts to the cameras, "I am the man of success of the millennium, if you don't want to listen to me, I'm done!", carries a deeply tragicomic dimension. From a grand monument and a living authority, he becomes a media icon – an image circulating online, a meme ripped out of context that effectively begins to overshadow his past, real achievements. Every society loves to create heroes, but is terrible at dealing with aging heros who disrupt their own continuations.

  1. The Prime Minister-Streamer (The Serial Phase)

Once the system becomes accustomed to the fact that all efficacy rests on one man, the political cost of replacing him becomes astronomical for his political camp. To maintain his position, the kamikaze must constantly prove that the crisis is ongoing and the state of emergency is permanent. He ceases to be an official and becomes a vessel for attention, a brand, a narrative format.

He transforms into a prime minister-streamer, who must daily provide the audience with the next episode of the political spectacle: what he wrote on platform X, whom he stung at the press conference, what meme he posted. The slogan "You must!" completely changes its meaning. It no longer means "Save us and restore order," but rather: "Do not leave the stage, keep the metrics up, because without you the show will end, and we will be struck by the mortal boredom of a procedural state."

  1. The Anti-Kamikaze (The Engineering Phase)

At the very end of this ladder appears a thoroughly modern figure, one that triggers a massive allergy in the traditional system of myths. This is the anti-kamikaze. A man who, when asked to step into the cockpit of an airplane, pulls out the technical blueprint, looks at the schematic, and says calmly: "Hold on a moment. Why does this plane have no landing gear? Why is there no landing provided for in the flight plan? What is Plan B, and who is supposed to replace me when I run out of fuel?"

The anti-kamikaze refuses to participate in the suicide flight not due to a lack of courage, but out of deep respect for logic and structures. He tells the crowd: "Let's not fix the pilot using the myth of sacrifice. Let's fix the construction of the plane." He is an extremely dangerous figure for the myth because he refuses to play the role and raises questions about procedures.

The Failure of Succession and the Triumph of Pudding

The greatest structural sin of the Amazing Kamikadze System is that it completely and permanently demolishes the mechanism of political succession. In a healthy, boring institutional structure, the departure of the boss does not trigger existential dread – another trained official takes his place, implements the procedures, and the system moves on. In a system built on the mythology of a hero, succession becomes impossible. For a new leader is not measured by the level of his substantive competence, but by the magnitude of the legend and charisma of his predecessor. And no one made of flesh and blood stands a chance against a myth.

Around the aging hero, a powerful fear of the void begins to grow. The political camp, the media, commentators, and even the voters themselves come to the conclusion that there is no other alternative bridge underneath. Therefore, the old one, even though it creaks terribly, rusts, and threatens to collapse, must be propped up at all costs.

Thus is born political "pudding." Pudding is not the result of the leader's biological aging. It is a collective product, a jam simmered together by the media providing the spotlights, the political camp panicking over the loss of influence, and the audience surrendering its attention. Everyone sees that the product is spent, but no one has the civic courage to close the project and phase out the myth, because no one knows how to talk about reality without using the name of the great protagonist. The hero becomes an actor who, after the closing credits, refuses to leave the dressing room and continues to parade through the streets in a dusty, theatrical costume, gathering increasingly sparse applause.

Reclaiming the Director of Waterworks

At this point, we arrive at the fundamental clash of two life and social attitudes. The first is born from a sense of lack of one's own efficacy: "A man who cannot find water begins to look for a Moses who will strike the rock with a staff." Such a person needs chieftains, saviors, and kamikazes. The second attitude is the domain of people who in the morning must open a shop, enter a classroom, repair a tractor, find a client, and sell a service. They have their own barricade to tend to, their own well to dig. They are not interested in grand narratives; they are interested in stability. They do not call out to authority in the language of messianism. They say: "Do your job and don't stop me from doing mine."

The greatest enemy of the political kamikaze is not his direct competitor from the opposition – both, after all, feed on the same fuel of continuous conflict and polarization. The greatest enemy of the heroic system is the bureaucratic "droid." A droid is nothing other than a procedure, an algorithm, an instruction, a quality standard, and a system of objective auditing. The droid ruthlessly executes point by point, operating completely independently of the mood, charisma, health, or social media reach of a specific human being. The droid says simply: "Anyone after brief training can execute this procedure. Point seven checked off, point eight implemented, water is flowing, next please."

For people who live off the continuous interpretation of the world, for the priests of political myths, influencers, and professional translators of reality, the world of droids is an absolute nightmare. In such a world, the demand for a daily spectacle drastically plummets. A droid does not generate reach, does not deliver grand emotions or a sense of participating in a great historical clash of good versus evil. It delivers only peace and quiet.

And modern societies, while declaring a love for peace and quiet, emotionally still require games. Therefore, instead of the common-sense sentence: "Manage the company, the company is not your property," they prefer to shout "You must!" from a safe distance.

It is time to finally ask that deeply uncomfortable, engineering question: Why does our system require the existence of heroes in the first place?

The state in its optimal, healthy version should not be a factory mass-producing kamikazes. It should be a smoothly oiled machine for delivering predictability to its citizens. The highest form of maturity for living in a modern democracy is the moment when the prime minister of a country begins to perform his function exactly like the director of the municipal waterworks.

Let us imagine this ideal: the guy is a deathly boring professional. No one builds monuments to him, no one organizes support marches under his window, no one shouts from a safe distance: "Director of waterworks, you must save the pressure in the pipes!". After his five-year term, citizens have absolutely no clue what this man's name was or what he looked like. And this is precisely the greatest possible success of the state. The awareness that no one had to die on a barricade, no one had to launch a daily stream from a fight for survival, and after turning the tap – simply, without any magic – clean water always flowed.

Society loves to buy tickets to screenings of Die Hard, but when it comes down to it, every one of us would like to live in a boring, safe, and predictable world where John McClane never, ever, had to be needed.